The 8 Greatest Brown Mascaras, All Editor-Examined 2023

Tester: Maki Yazawa, meals author

Eye shade: Brown

“I’ve been utilizing Too Confronted Higher Than Intercourse in black because it first launched again in 2013 (yep, a decade in the past). This mascara is principally the holy grail of lifting and volumizing in a single. But it surely wasn’t till lately that I switched to brown; frankly, I’m by no means going again. The brown shade errs extra on the facet of darkish chocolate, which enhances my darkish brown eyes a lot better than the lighter brown mascaras available on the market. The thick wand makes making use of and, most significantly, volumizing my lashes almost easy—a number of swipes and my lashes are giving Major Character power.

I even have extraordinarily delicate eyes, and this is among the few mascaras that don’t make my eyes itch or water. Though the formulation isn’t technically waterproof (within the brown shade, a minimum of), I discover that this product doesn’t flake off or smudge simply by any means. Working example: It may well face up to a scorching yoga class so long as I keep away from rubbing my eyes excessively.”

Shades: 2

Cruelty-free: Sure

Waterproof: No

Tester: Amelia McBride, editorial assistant

Eye shade: hazel

“There are 1,000,000 the reason why I like Covergirl’s Lash Blast Quantity brown mascara, however for time’s sake, I’ll share just some.

For one, it’s solely $9; some luxurious manufacturers cost as a lot as $30-$40 for a tube. Second, the comb is product of rubber, which suggests the bristles keep in place and received’t warp or bend over time. Third, this components is tremendous thick and delivers prompt size and quantity. If I’m in a rush, only one coat will do the trick. Lastly, this brown shade has purple undertones which make the inexperienced elements of my hazel eyes actually pop!”

Shades: 5

Cruelty-free: Sure

Waterproof: No

Eye shade: brown

As a result of I’ve quick lashes, it’s all the time a battle to seek out smudge-resistant mascara. At $32 per tube, Dior’s Iconic Overcurl is among the dearer mascaras on the checklist, nevertheless it’s price splurging on. Not solely does the wealthy, chocolate-brown shade complement my brown eyes, it volumizes and lifts my quick lashes sans smudging. I’ve run, incline walked, and worn the Overcurl in 100-degree Texas warmth. Did it smudge? No. Did it maintain up? Sure. Was my mascara nonetheless delivering appears to be like eight hours later? Heck yea.

I actually appreciated the curved brush, which was nice at coating every of my lashes. Even my lashes on my interior tear duct weren’t missed. It’s packaged in a flowery silver tube with the Dior brand (sure, I’m a snobby Taurus who’s a sucker for packaging). One factor to contemplate: it does take a number of further swipes to get a fuller and extra dramatic look. The extra I swipe, the fuller the look. It’s a win-win.

Shades: 3

Cruelty-free: No

Waterproof: No

Tester: Jenny Heimlich, senior health and well being editor

Eye shade: blue

“As somebody with truthful pores and skin and blue eyes, I sometimes attain for a brown mascara, however I discover some variations are too mild and delicate to do a lot for me. So I like that Tarte’s is a wealthy chocolate brown that’s darkish sufficient to make a press release however nonetheless enhances my pure coloring. The components provides good size and quantity to my lashes with out clumping. Additionally: It stays put for a very long time. This mascara guarantees to final for twenty-four hours, and I discovered it actually caught on my lashes that lengthy, although it will get a bit flaky by the top of that interval.

The packaging is tremendous enjoyable! The surface of the tube is purple snakeskin materials, which makes me really feel like I’m preparing for a celebration. It’s straightforward to open and doesn’t make a large number. I didn’t expertise any irritation, however I wouldn’t say I essentially have tremendous delicate eyes. This mascara is vegan and cruelty-free. The components consists of components like rice bran, wax, vitamin C and B5, and olive esters to situation, hydrate, and shield your lashes. I recognize that it additionally is available in a smaller journey dimension.”

Shades: 2

Cruelty-free: No

Waterproof: No

Tester: Betty Gold, senior meals editor

Eye shade: blue

“This mascara each lifted and lengthened my lashes. It was a really delicate, tender brown, which I beloved. The mascara had nice packaging. It didn’t make a large number when opening or on my face. Rating! I do have delicate eyes, and this mascara didn’t irritate my eyes. One other function price noting? It’s waterproof and has a vegan components. One in every of my favourite issues about this mascara is that it really isn’t clumpy. A really, very uncommon discover and a time saver, in my view—making an attempt to comb by means of your lashes time and again to get them to fan out and separate is tedious. None of that with this!”

Shades: 3

Cruelty-free: No

Waterproof: Sure

Tester: Kara Brown, magnificence author

Eye shade: Brown

“Though this was a enjoyable experiment, I can’t say I’ll attain for brown mascara once more. As a result of my pores and skin is brown and my hair is tremendous darkish brown, placing on this Pixi mascara made my lashes lighter than common and fewer noticeable towards my pores and skin tone. They’re nonetheless seen, however as a result of I’ve quick lashes I would like mascara that makes my lashes pop as a substitute of constructing them extra delicate. The components went on and stayed on nicely.”

Shades: 2

Cruelty-free: Sure

Waterproof: No, however water resistant

Tester: Maki Yazawa, meals author

Eye shade: Brown

“Relating to excellent mascara, I search for ones that obtain lengthy, non-clumpy, but voluminous lashes multi functional. And Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Speak Volumizing Mascara delivers on all of these fronts. (In fact, I’ve but to come across a Charlotte Tilbury product I don’t like.) From the glossy packaging to the high-quality formulation, Charlotte Tilbury’s mascara hits the mark. It has a barely auburn hue, which provides my lashes a delicate tint, excellent for a no-makeup, make-up kind of day.

That mentioned, this brown shade with reddish undertones would additionally look stunning on of us with green-colored or hazel eyes. It’s additionally price noting that certainly one of my favourite elements about this product is the mascara brush that’s constructed with “load and comb” expertise meant to offer your lashes a “push-up” impact—and, boy, does it work. The one draw back of this mascara is that you just do want so as to add a number of layers if you wish to obtain that tremendous va-va-voom voluminous look—however a number of further swipes will simply do the trick.”

Shades: 2

Cruelty-free: Sure

Waterproof: No

Tester: Danielle Calma

Eye shade: Brown

“This mascara makes my eyelashes seem like they’re thrice their unique size with out making it seem like I’m sporting any mascara in any respect. In contrast to many different mascaras I’ve used prior to now, this one went on with out clumping, no matter what number of coats I piled on—and due to its skinny wand, it allowed me to focus on every lash with precision whereas the brushes separated my lashes for a lifted and fanned-out look. (Simply take into account that it received’t make lashes seem super-thick, a minimum of in my expertise).

What’s extra, a few coats have been greater than sufficient to take my lashes to new heights. I put this mascara by means of the wringer, utilizing it one afternoon when temperatures have been above 80-degrees and even after six hours within the warmth, I used to be happy to seek out that it stayed put.”

Shades: 2

Cruelty-free: Sure

Waterproof: No