I Examined Over a Dozen Liquid Eyeliners, Right here Are My Favs


Share post:

With the Effectively+Good SHOP, our editors put their years of know-how to work with the intention to decide merchandise (from skincare to self care and past) they’re betting you’ll love. Whereas our editors independently choose these merchandise, making a purchase order via our hyperlinks might earn Effectively+Good a fee. Pleased procuring! Discover the SHOP

If magnificence historical past has taught us something, it’s that make-up tendencies come and go, however winged liner is without end. Regardless of this, liquid eyeliner stays, in my view, one of many trickiest make-up merchandise to grasp. I personally have been carrying winged liner on and off since I used to be within the seventh grade (humble brag), and I nonetheless maintain my breath in nervousness each time I apply it. And positive, my questionable cat-eye approach may undoubtedly take among the blame, however the liquid eyeliners you’re utilizing can actually make or break the expertise.

Sort of like discovering a signature scent, selecting a liquid eyeliner is private. Everybody’s wants are totally different—of us with hooded eyes might need a transfer-proof system, for instance, or these with oily lids might need a matte, waterproof end. My liquid eyeliner standards is fairly easy: I need my liner of option to have a versatile tip that lends itself to a feline flick, and I need it to final all day with out transferring to my lids. To search out this mystical eyeliner of desires, I put over a dozen high-end and drugstore liquid liners to the take a look at.  Learn on for my ultimate rating, and the one system that got here out on high.


honest beauty liquid eyeliner on one side and alexa wearing the eyeliner on the other side

Sincere Magnificence, Liquid Eyeliner — $13.00

I need to admit, the Sincere Magnificence Liquid Eyeliner took me unexpectedly—the system is richly pigmented at first stroke, and delivers a daring matte end. And whereas the ink properly format does have a little bit of a studying curve, retains the felt tip saturated always. My solely gripes are the truth that the system takes a stable 20 seconds to dry down, and that it transferred a bit on my oily lids. However given the reasonably priced price ticket, it’s nothing a bit of primer or shadow can’t repair.

  • Inkwell doesn’t dry out
  • Pigmented system
  • Matte end
  • Reasonably priced
  • Slight studying curve
  • Takes time to dry down
  • Transfers


glossier pro tip liner on one side and an image of alexa wearing the eyeliner on the other

Glossier, Professional Tip — $18.00

The pioneers of simple no-makeup-makeup, I used to be anticipating Glossier’s Professional Tip Liquid Liner to be as user-friendly as every part else of their lineup—and it’s. The versatile brush provides you a exact line that’s good for a refined cat-eye flick. The system goes on semi-sheer which is an efficient factor for inexperienced persons who’re nervous about going overboard with their liner, however is perhaps a con for individuals who desire a extra daring, graphic look. The excellent news is that it’s buildable—it simply takes a bit extra time to get an opaque end—and lengthy carrying, with zero smudging or switch.

  • Versatile brush tip
  • Lengthy-wearing system
  • Newbie-friendly
  • Nice for minimal liner
  • Sheer system
  • Dries out shortly, in response to different reviewers


kvd beauty tattoo liner on one side and alexa wearing the eyeliner on the other side

KVD Magnificence, Tattoo Liner — $23.00

For those who love winged eyeliner, then you definately’ve in all probability tried the KVD Magnificence Tattoo Liner. It’s been a very long time best-seller for good cause—the exact brush tip gives loads of flexibility for daring and minimal feline flicks alike. And the easy-to-use pen truly lives as much as its waterproof claims, making it oily-lid pleasant (although if you’d like it to be further budge proof, I like to recommend utilizing a primer). The one caveat in my view is that it takes a few strokes to attain full pigment—however the buildable system makes layering simple, and by no means pulls up on itself or skips whereas making use of.

  • Exact brush tip
  • Doesn’t dry out shortly
  • Waterproof system
  • Can be utilized for refined and graphic liner seems to be
  • Straightforward to make use of
  • Must be constructed up for full pigment
  • Might require primer for optimum endurance


pat mcgrath liquid eyeliner on one side and alexa wearing the eyeliner on the other

Pat McGrath Labs, Perma Precision Liquid Eyeliner — $34.00

I like the daring matte end on the Perma Precision Eyeliner by Pat McGrath Labs. In contrast to different felt tip liners I’ve tried, the tip on this liner has some give to it, providing sufficient flexibility for a fluid cat eye flick. The pigmented, excessive protection system dries down shortly, nevertheless it did switch a bit on my oily lids, so I’d advocate setting it with a powder or utilizing a budge proof primer earlier than making use of to get essentially the most out of its waterproof system. Some Sephora customers additionally claimed that this one dried out shortly, however that hasn’t been my expertise. Simply retailer the liner the wrong way up to maintain the felt tip saturated.

  • Waterproof system
  • Versatile felt tip
  • Daring shade payoff
  • Matte end
  • Reviewers say it dries out shortly
  • May switch on oily lids


nyx epic ink eyeliner and alexa wearing the eyeliner on the other side

NYX, Epic Ink Liner — $8.00

Initially $10, now $8

This drugstore liner is claimed to be a extra reasonably priced dupe for the KVD Tattoo Liner…and I type of agree. The Epic Ink Liner is simply as user-friendly, has an equally exact brush tip, and a dependable waterproof system that stays put. Dare I say that the pigment on this one is much more intense and excessive protection than the KVD liner? One swipe does the trick with this one and I barely ever need to layer it. When the warmth and humidity are at its peak right here in Miami, I do use a primer with it as insurance coverage.

  • Dries down shortly
  • Waterproof system
  • Exact brush tip
  • Newbie pleasant
  • Pigmented system
  • Reasonably priced
  • Requires a primer on sizzling and humid days
  • Brush tip frays if you happen to’re not cautious


maybelline tattoo studio liquid liner on one side and a photo of alexa wearing the eyeliner on the other

Maybelline, Tattoo Studio Liquid Ink Eyeliner — $8.00

For those who’re a winged liner aficionado, you’re going to need to snag this in your subsequent journey to the pharmacy. Maybelline’s Liquid Ink Eyeliner requires some apply to grasp the inkwell format, however when you get it, the long-wearing system holds up. The applicator’s exact felt tip helped me obtain a pointy, clear line, and the pigmented black shade retains its influence all through the day with out transferring. Plus, it’s underneath $10—which you’ll be able to’t beat! Simply notice that if you happen to’re a fan of a matte end, the Tattoo Studio Liquid Ink boasts a satin look.

  • Lengthy-wearing system
  • Hooded eye pleasant, in response to evaluations
  • Doesn’t switch
  • Inkwell format doesn’t dry out
  • Exact felt tip
  • Wouldn’t advocate for inexperienced persons
  • Comes off in flakes after day lengthy put on


ilia liquid eyeliner on one side and alexa wearing the eyeliner on the other

Ilia, Clear Line Liquid Eyeliner — $28.00

Ilia Clear Line Liquid Eyeliner guarantees an additional positive tip good for a exact liner look—and it completely delivers. It glides on effortlessly with out skipping or tugging on my lids, and the system is daring and pigmented with each stroke. And if you happen to’re the kind of one that likes to edit their feline flick with a cotton swab (I’m), Ilia’s easy-to-remove system makes touching up your liner simple—making this user-friendly pen a dream for inexperienced persons. The one con is that the system is perhaps a bit of too simple to take away, and requires a bit of assist from a primer or powder to keep away from transferring and smudging. I used Ilia’s skin-smoothing liquid eyeshadow as a base and that labored superbly!

  • Extremely-fine felt tip
  • Pigmented system
  • Matte end
  • Newbie-friendly
  • Straightforward to take away
  • Transfers on oily lids
  • Wants a primer/powder


rare beauty liquid eyeliner on one side and a photo of alexa wearing the liner on the other

Uncommon Magnificence, Excellent Strokes Matte Liquid Liner — $19.00

Uncommon Magnificence Excellent Strokes Matte Liquid Liner has over 1,000 vegan bristles in its versatile brush tip, making it simple to attain quite a lot of liner seems to be—from daring graphics to specific, minimalist wings. The pen can also be a bit taller than all the different liquid eyeliners that I attempted, which I discovered to make utility even simpler. What’s extra, it packs severe pigment, giving me clean and opaque matte ink that’s really waterproof. And in response to some Sephora customers, the budge-proof system is nice for folk with hooded lids too!

  • Waterproof system
  • Versatile brush tip
  • Matte and pigmented system
  • Easy and straightforward to use
  • Nice for hooded lids, in response to evaluations


benefit roller liner image on one side and alexa wearing the liquid eyeliner on the other side

Profit Cosmetics, Curler Liner Waterproof Eyeliner — $22.00

In all of my liquid eyeliner analysis, I used to be starting to assume I most popular brush tip eyeliners—till I attempted the Profit Curler Liner. The felt tip tapers to an additional positive level for further precision that’s nonetheless tremendous versatile, and it delivers clean strokes of pigmented (really matte) ink. Whereas the Sephora evaluations are diverse, all I can say is that this system was extremely lengthy lasting on me! With no smudging, bleeding, or transferring in sight. Plus if you wish to take it for a take a look at run earlier than getting the total measurement, you possibly can all the time purchase a mini model.

  • Really waterproof system
  • Matte end
  • Additional positive felt tip
  • Very pigmented
  • Dries too quick in response to some evaluations


l'oreal infallible grip precision felt tip liquid liner on one side and an image of alexa wearing it on the other side

L’Oreal Paris, Infallible Grip Precision Felt Eyeliner — $9.00

Initially $12, now $9

Of all of the liquid eyeliners on this listing, this L’Oreal eyeliner ticks all of my containers. I even used it on my wedding ceremony day—exterior within the Miami humidity—which is de facto saying one thing. The positive felt tip delivers a razor sharp wing that’s *truly* waterproof, and lasts all day and evening on me. It’s user-friendly, and excellent for drawing on refined child wings and artsy, graphic designs like. And after a stable three months of semi-consistent use (I did have to check the opposite liners on this listing, natch), the liner pen has maintained all of its clean, black pigment with out getting dry and crusty. Plus, it’s so reasonably priced!

  • Waterproof
  • Wonderful felt tip
  • Doesn’t switch
  • Straightforward to make use of
  • Nice for daring and refined wings
  • Reasonably priced

And the liquid eyeliners that weren’t for me…

Freck, Lashrocket Liquid Liner $24

I had excessive hopes for the Freck Lashrocket Liquid Liner the second I learn that it comprises lash boosting peptides (who wouldn’t be sport for a liner and lash serum in a single?), however fact be advised, it type of fell flat for me. On the one hand, the inkwell liner format helps preserve it from drying out like some liner pens are vulnerable to do. However the applicator’s further lengthy deal with is awkward to carry and the stiff felt tip makes it troublesome to attain that curved cat-eye look. The ink itself is on the sheer facet, and went on a bit streaky the extra I attempted to construct it up.

Profit Cosmetics, They’re Actual! Xtreme Precision Eye Liner $24

I’m a agency believer in Profit’s budge-proof They’re Actual Mascara system, so I used to be psyched to see if the model’s Xtreme Precision Eye Liner packed the identical resilient punch. And whereas the positive brush tip was *extraordinarily* exact and glided on with out skipping or tugging, I’m bummed to report that regardless of its waterproof claims, the liner didn’t put on properly on me and transferred inside just a few hours. I additionally discovered the ink itself to be fairly sheer, and required a number of layers to get the specified shade payoff.

Effectively Individuals, Recent Traces Black Liquid Eyeliner $17

I used to be instantly intrigued by Effectively Individuals’s Recent Traces Liquid Eyeliner for its good-for-you system—it comprises aloe vera and rosemary to assist hydrate and soothe eyes. The inkwell format retains the liner’s felt tip moist with ink so you may get these nourishing components proper in your lash line. The one drawback is, the system stays moist as soon as utilized which led to numerous smudging. What’s extra, the black ink doesn’t convey that intense pigment I crave in my liquid liners. You’ll be able to layer it to construct up the pigment in fact, however that solely made the moist system harder to work with.

Need to be the primary to listen to concerning the newest (and biggest) SHOP product drops, customized collections, reductions, and extra? Signal as much as have the intel delivered straight to your inbox.

Our editors independently choose these merchandise. Making a purchase order via our hyperlinks might earn Effectively+Good a fee.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles