Are Electrolyte Dietary supplements a Rip-off?


Share post:

Electrolyte dietary supplements are experiencing a increase.

Endurance athletes have been taking them throughout workouts and races for many years, however not too long ago, they’ve change into fashionable with everybody—from Crossfitters to tennis champions to sofa potatoes. 

You should purchase customized electrolyte dietary supplements, blood assessments to measure your electrolyte ranges, and myriad hydration drinks, chews, tablets, powders, and gels that promise to maintain your blood brimful of electrolytes.

Why the clamor for these salty dietary supplements?

In keeping with the businesses peddling these merchandise, while you sweat, you lose massive quantities of electrolytes like sodium, potassium, and magnesium. Should you don’t replenish these very important minerals, you shortly change into dehydrated, and your efficiency, temper, and total well being withers. 

Is that this true, although? 

Are electrolytes the keystone of well being and efficiency they’re puffed as much as be?

And do you actually need to refresh your electrolyte ranges with particular dietary supplements, or are you able to get all the pieces you want from meals? 

Preserve studying to study what science says.

What Are Electrolyte Dietary supplements?

The scientific definition of an electrolyte is a compound which produces optimistic or destructive ions when dissolved in a liquid, like water. 

On the subject of diet, the time period electrolyte refers particularly to a handful of minerals (the primary ones being sodium, potassium, magnesium, phosphate, chloride, calcium, and bicarbonate) that when dissolved in bodily fluids create electrically charged ions.

These compounds create an inner surroundings that’s conducive to many bodily capabilities, together with muscle contraction, nerve perform, tissue restore, hydration, and nutrient absorption. 

An electrolyte complement is just a product that incorporates a mixture of electrolytes, usually sodium, with small quantities of potassium and magnesium. Most electrolyte dietary supplements are available a powder that you simply combine with water after which drink, however you can even purchase them in ready-to-drink types in addition to tablets or capsules, and bars, gels, and chews. 

Among the hottest electrolyte dietary supplements embrace Gatorade, Powerade, Nuun, Pedialyte, LMNT, Jelly Stomach Sport Beans, ONNIT HYDRATech, Ultima Replenisher, Liquid I.V., and Propel, and it’s change into a cliché for professional athletes to launch their very own model of electrolyte drink. Most of those merchandise additionally include carbohydrates and amino acids, however all of them underline electrolytes of their advertising and marketing.

You can even discover many electrolyte dietary supplements marketed as hydration dietary supplements, because it’s claimed that supplementing with electrolytes is important to staying hydrated (extra on this in a second). 

Why Do Folks Take Electrolyte Dietary supplements?

Most individuals take electrolyte dietary supplements to remain hydrated, particularly when figuring out in sizzling, humid environments. 

Should you don’t take further electrolytes, complement corporations declare, your physique’s retailer of electrolytes will shortly dwindle, resulting in decreased efficiency, mind fog, fatigue, muscle cramps, and finally heatstroke, fainting, and even dying.

As you’ll be able to think about, this has made electrolyte dietary supplements a hobbyhorse amongst athletes, particularly endurance athletes, who usually do intense exercises and competitions in sizzling environments. 

As an example, it’s widespread to see triathletes, cyclists, runners, and tennis, basketball, soccer, and soccer gamers sipping electrolyte drinks throughout exercises and competitions and rhapsodizing about their advantages on social media. 

Analysis exhibits that this boosterism of electrolyte dietary supplements works too. One examine carried out by scientists at Loyola College Medical Heart discovered that 58% of the runners sampled mentioned that they drank sports activities drinks that contained electrolytes to stop sagging blood sodium ranges.

Why Electrolyte Dietary supplements Are a Waste of Cash

Electrolyte dietary supplements are minimize from the identical material as BCAAs (“branch-chained amino acids”)—tasty water that doesn’t ship on any of their “science-based” guarantees. 

The reality is that electrolyte dietary supplements have been extensively studied, and most analysis exhibits that they’re no higher than ingesting plain water: they don’t enhance efficiency, don’t forestall muscle cramps, and don’t show you how to keep hydrated. 

As a substitute, they provide you a tiny dose of minerals that you would simply get from meals for a fraction of the value. 

Let’s have a look at the scientific proof to study why.

Electrolyte dietary supplements don’t enhance efficiency.

The primary cause folks drink electrolyte dietary supplements is to enhance their athletic efficiency, or, extra particularly, to keep off the (purported) drop in efficiency that happens while you hemorrhage electrolytes throughout train.

For instance, Gatorade claims their Thirst Quencher beverage is “. . . probably the most scientifically researched and game-tested option to change the electrolytes you lose in sweat” and depends on various celeb endorsements f like LeBron James, Serena Williams, Tiger Woods, and Michael Jordan to affirm their product. 

That is the substance of most electrolyte complement advertising and marketing: drink (or eat) our electrolytes, and also you’ll be a greater athlete. 

This whole argument hinges on the concept you lose massive quantities of electrolytes (particularly sodium) while you sweat, and that this lack of electrolytes results in poor efficiency. Whilst you additionally lose small quantities of potassium, magnesium, and different minerals throughout train, sodium is the primary one, and thus usually utilized in research as a proxy for total electrolyte losses.

In keeping with complement corporations, electrolyte loss significantly harms “salty sweaters”—individuals who supposedly lose way more sodium and different electrolytes by way of sweat than common.  

Should you have a look at the precise science, although, you’ll see this declare is smoke and mirrors. 

Even with no science-based, standardized definition of what a “salty” sweater is, this situation nonetheless isn’t sufficient to warrant supplementation. As train physiologist Ross Tucker explains in a sequence of glorious articles on his web site, even the “saltiest” of sweaters solely lose a small quantity of electrolytes after they perspire. 

In truth, sweat has a a lot decrease focus of electrolytes than your blood. (In science jargon, your sweat is hypotonic, or much less salty, than your blood.) Particularly, your blood incorporates about 140 millimoles (mM) of sodium per liter, whereas sweat incorporates nearer to 20-to-60 mM/L. If you sweat, the focus of electrolytes in your physique really rises, since you lose way more water than sodium, potassium, and different electrolytes. 

What’s extra, the low focus of electrolytes in drinks like Gatorade, Powerade, Cytomax, and so forth barely strikes the needle in altering your physique’s electrolyte chemistry. As an example, if a runner loses about two liters of sweat throughout a two-hour run and solely drinks one liter of water, he’ll lose about 4.6 grams of sodium (that’s assuming he’s a “salty sweater,” by the best way). If he as a substitute downs a sports activities drink, he’ll nonetheless lose about 4.2 grams of sodium—too insignificant a distinction to vary his blood sodium ranges or to have an effect on his efficiency. (You might get the identical quantity of sodium by sprinkling ⅙ teaspoon of standard desk salt in your meals).

This lack of impression was demonstrated in a examine carried out at Pennsylvania State College. Scientists confirmed that individuals who drank water or Gatorade throughout runs wound up with the identical blood concentrations of sodium afterward. In different phrases, whilst you do lose some electrolytes in your sweat, the quantities are too small to matter, and are simply replenished over the course of the day from consuming regular meals. 

That is true even throughout excessive endurance train, as demonstrated in a examine on Ironman triathletes on the College of Cape City. On this examine, the scientists divided 413 triathletes competing within the 2001 Cape City Ironman into three teams: an electrolyte group that consumed salt tablets, a placebo group that consumed starch tablets, and a management group that didn’t eat any particular dietary supplements. 

Every salt pill contained 620 mg of desk salt (sodium chloride), and the athletes have been inspired to eat 1-to-4 tablets per hour. On common, they ended up downing about 3.6 grams of pure sodium through the race (sodium chloride is about 40% sodium, so the runners ate a mean of 9 salt tablets through the race).

The consequence? 

All three teams’ blood ranges of sodium have been throughout the regular, wholesome vary—taking electrolyte dietary supplements made completely no distinction. The scientists concluded that “. . . sodium supplementation was not needed [emphasis mine] to protect serum sodium concentrations in athletes competing for about 12 hours in an Ironman triathlon.”

(And in case you’re questioning, on March 19, 2001 when the race came about, the temperature was about 65-to-85 ℉ a lot of the day. These of us misplaced a number of gallons of sweat apiece, and nonetheless didn’t want salt tablets to maintain their electrolyte ranges topped off.)

Additional bolstering these findings, a examine revealed in 2018 in The Worldwide Journal of Sports activities Science reviewed 5 research on the results of sodium supplementation on endurance efficiency and concluded that “there may be minimal proof to attract a hyperlink between sodium ingestion and endurance efficiency.” In different phrases, most research discovered no profit to taking sodium dietary supplements.

Some salty (sorry, couldn’t resist) electrolyte zealots sniff at these research and declare that you must eat a lot bigger quantities of sodium to see advantages (and different electrolytes too), however that is daft for 2 causes:

  1. First, most research (together with the one on Ironman triathletes) have discovered that individuals who don’t eat electrolyte dietary supplements nonetheless have wholesome, regular ranges of electrolytes of their blood, and there’s no proof that goosing them additional would enhance efficiency. 
  2. Second, even when you may choke down massive quantities of salt throughout train, it wouldn’t essentially be absorbed and will result in different issues.

As train physiologist and diet scientist Dr. Stacy Sims has identified, while you eat a lot of salt, this could “pull” water out of your bloodstream and into your intestines as your physique tries to dilute the salt focus in your digestive system (a course of generally known as reverse water flux). 

Whereas this isn’t a giant deal at relaxation (go forward and luxuriate in that pizza), it will possibly result in bloating, sloshing, and abdomen cramps whereas figuring out. And once more—it’s pointless. Consuming that a lot salt whereas coaching doesn’t supply any advantages over ingesting water.

The underside line? Electrolyte dietary supplements are a busted flush on the subject of bettering efficiency. 

Your physique is extraordinarily adept at regulating its sodium and electrolyte ranges throughout train by controlling your thirst, and also you don’t lose sufficient salt, potassium or every other electrolyte throughout train to profit from supplementation. 

Electrolyte dietary supplements don’t forestall muscle cramps.

One other oft-touted declare is that you may forestall or remedy muscle cramps by swigging electrolyte dietary supplements earlier than, throughout, and after coaching. 

Supposedly, a lack of electrolytes disrupts muscular signaling in such a approach that your nerves “quick circuit,” resulting in workout-killing charley horses. Like a automotive operating low on oil, when your electrolyte ranges peter out, the machine grinds to a halt.

Clever advertising and marketing, but in addition piffle. 

Scientists nonetheless aren’t certain about what precisely causes muscle cramps, however analysis has proven time after time that electrolyte depletion isn’t the wrongdoer. 

One significantly illuminating examine carried out by scientists on the College of Cape City measured the electrolyte ranges and incidence of muscle cramps in 72 runners within the Two Oceans Ultramarathon, a 35-mile foot race that snakes across the mountains of southern Africa. Forty-five of the runners additionally had a historical past of muscle cramps whereas operating.

In contrast to many research, which solely measured sodium ranges, these researchers subjected the runners to a bevy of blood assessments earlier than, instantly after, and 60 minutes after the race. They measured the runners’ ranges of sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium, in addition to varied markers of hydration corresponding to blood, plasma, and crimson blood cell quantity, and blood osmolality.  

The consequence? 

The researchers discovered no relationship between the runner’s electrolyte ranges and their incidence or severity of cramping. In different phrases, individuals who skilled frequent, extreme muscle cramps through the race have been no extra more likely to have low electrolyte ranges than individuals who didn’t cramp. In addition they discovered no affiliation between cramping and dehydration.

One latest scientific evaluation carried out by scientists on the Shanghai Analysis Institute even instructed that excessive ranges of electrolytes may catalyze muscle cramps. The researchers speculated that since dehydration usually causes plasma electrolyte ranges to rise, this might muddle nerve indicators associated to muscular contraction, resulting in cramps. That is nonetheless only a principle, nonetheless, and most research have discovered zero affiliation between cramping and electrolyte ranges, whether or not excessive or low.

So, if having low electrolyte ranges doesn’t trigger cramps, what does? 

Scientists haven’t discovered a smoking gun, however one of many strongest present theories is that cramps are the results of “altered neuromuscular management.” Mainly, there’s a disruption within the electrical indicators that trigger muscle tissues to contract, which makes them contract too lengthy and on the mistaken occasions. 

It’s not clear what causes this pesky phenomenon, however probably the most believable theories embrace racing at a better depth than you’ve educated for (pushing your self a lot tougher than regular), coaching in situations you aren’t accustomed to (corresponding to extremely popular, humid climate), or not consuming sufficient carbs earlier than or throughout exercising (muscle glycogen depletion)—principally, insufficient preparation for the calls for of the game.

Probe round on-line and also you’ll discover many individuals who attempt to poke holes on this analysis, however dig into the small print, and also you’ll discover all of them boil all the way down to tales:

“My buddy’s spouse, who’s a health care provider and a triathlete, says she all the time takes electrolytes whereas coaching . . .” 

“[insert social media influencer here] swears by [insert low cost, high-margin electrolyte supplement]. You suppose you realize higher than him/her?”

“I don’t care what the science says—I haven’t had a single cramp since I began taking electrolyte dietary supplements.” 

Should you’re swayed by these arguments, then by all means take a flyer on electrolyte dietary supplements. Simply know that science says they’re no higher than water, and that you simply’ll in all probability have higher luck beating off cramps by bettering your coaching, not slurping salty sports activities drinks.

Electrolyte dietary supplements don’t show you how to keep hydrated.

In a intelligent sleight of hand, many complement corporations have tried to redefine dehydration as a lack of fluid and electrolytes. That is why you’ll usually see electrolyte dietary supplements branded as hydration dietary supplements, as in the event that they have been equal.

We are able to begin to unravel this facile line of reasoning by flipping open The Oxford English Dictionary, which defines dehydration as “the loss or elimination of water from one thing” and “a dangerous discount within the quantity of water within the physique.” 

Discover how the phrase “electrolyte” doesn’t seem wherever?

Semantic arguments apart, electrolytes do play a job in sustaining correct hydration ranges, however your physique has no hassle sustaining ample electrolyte ranges with out supplementation, even throughout 12+-hour-long exercises within the warmth.

Some electrolyte hucksters will counter that though electrolytes don’t immediately show you how to keep hydrated, they not directly assist by encouraging you to drink extra fluid. They often comply with this by reciting the well-worn and misguided statistic that dropping even 1-to-2% of your physique weight (a proxy for physique water) can scale back your athletic efficiency by 10% or extra.

Thus, if even gentle dehydration banjaxes your efficiency . . . and ingesting extra helps you keep away from dehydration . . . and electrolyte dietary supplements show you how to drink extra . . . then electrolyte dietary supplements show you how to keep away from dehydration . . . or so the fallacy goes. 

As soon as once more, this syllogism is sophistry.

The primary a part of this argument is true—most individuals naturally drink extra of a salty electrolyte drink than plain water when given the selection—however this isn’t fascinating.

After years of being bombarded with advertising and marketing messages in regards to the significance of hydration, many athletes have developed a monomaniacal give attention to ingesting as a lot water as attainable. You’ll usually hear folks say that you must “Drink large,” or that you need to “Drink earlier than you get thirsty—by that point it’s too late!,” or “Drink sufficient that you simply don’t lose any physique weight by the top of your exercise.” 

Not solely is that this hand-wringing over hydration pointless, it decreases efficiency and is doubtlessly harmful.

Research have repeatedly proven that gentle dehydration—often round 1-to-5%—doesn’t impair efficiency in runners, cyclists, and different athletes in balmy, sizzling, or humid situations, and that forcing your self to drink greater than required to quench your thirst doesn’t enhance efficiency and should even lower it. 

The quickest athletes additionally are inclined to be probably the most dehydrated on the finish of races. Some of the excessive examples of that is the runner Haile Gebrselassie, who misplaced 9.8% of his physique weight in the midst of successful the 2009 Dubai Marathon in a time of two:05:29. 

The underside line is that people are completely able to dropping reasonable quantities of fluid whereas racing and coaching, and haven’t any downside rehydrating later within the day by merely “ingesting to thirst.”

Guzzling extreme quantities of fluid—with or with out electrolytes—may also shortly dilute the electrolyte focus of your blood, resulting in a situation generally known as exercise-associated hyponatremia (EAH), aka water intoxication

This situation kills way more folks than dehydration, and can also be tougher to rectify as soon as it units in. One of the best ways to keep away from this is to drink to thirst, which is able to often result in a small, innocent diploma of dehydration by the top of your exercise or race that can naturally resolve itself all through the day. 

There’s way more that might be mentioned in regards to the issues of overhydration, however within the remaining evaluation, the info exhibits two issues: 

  1. You don’t want electrolyte dietary supplements or drinks to hydrate—plain water is okay. 
  2. You don’t have to make your self drink greater than your thirst dictates. In truth, doing so may impair your efficiency and endanger your well being if taken to extremes.

They’re low cost, aggressively marketed, and style good. 

That’s it. 

Electrolyte dietary supplements are actually simply powders or tablets containing cheap minerals that you may simply get from meals, often blended with some flavors, sweeteners, and dyes, and wrapped in glittery packaging.  

This consists of Gatorade and nearly each different sports activities drink you’ll be able to consider, in addition to the entire gimcrack hydration dietary supplements which might be omnipresent at endurance competitions, in gyms, and on-line. 

Now, none of that is to say that hydration dietary supplements are dangerous for you. Whereas they’ll trigger some issues with gastric discomfort and overhydration, that is usually solely a difficulty while you eat a whole lot of them throughout a protracted exercise or race. Sipping some electrolyte drink between units within the health club isn’t a giant deal.

Nevertheless it’s not doing something for you, both—it’s nonetheless simply tasty, costly water.

+ Scientific References


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles