Analysis Roundup 14: Mild vs. Heavy Weightlifting, Breakfast and Weight Loss, and L-Theanine and Stress


Share post:

It’s estimated that there are over 2+ million scientific papers printed every year, and this firehose solely appears to accentuate.

Even in the event you slim your focus to health analysis, it could take a number of lifetimes to unravel the hairball of research on vitamin, coaching, supplementation, and associated fields.

For this reason my group and I spend hundreds of hours every year dissecting and describing scientific research in articles, podcasts, and books and utilizing the outcomes to formulate our 100% all-natural sports activities dietary supplements and inform our teaching providers. 

And whereas the ideas of correct consuming and exercising are easy and considerably immutable, reviewing new analysis can reinforce or reshape how we eat, prepare, and dwell for the higher. 

Thus, every week, I’m going to share three scientific research on food plan, train, supplementation, mindset, and life-style that may assist you acquire muscle and energy, lose fats, carry out and really feel higher, dwell longer, and get and keep more healthy. 

This week, you’ll learn the way lifting mild weights compares to lifting heavy weights for muscle acquire, whether or not or not consuming breakfast will help you shed extra pounds, and why L-theanine could also be an precise “chill tablet.” 


You could possibly acquire simply as a lot muscle utilizing “mild” weights as “heavy” weights.

Supply: “Adjustments in Physique Composition and Energy after 12 Weeks of Excessive-Depth Practical coaching with Two Totally different Hundreds in Bodily Energetic Males and Ladies: A Randomized Managed Examine” printed on November 12, 2021 in Sports activities.

If you first dip your toes into the world of weightlifting, right here’s the coaching recommendation you’re more likely to hear: 

  1. If you wish to acquire energy, raise heavy weights for low reps (corresponding to 85+% of your one-rep max for five reps or much less).
  2. If you wish to enhance your endurance, raise mild weights for prime reps (corresponding to 30% of your 1RM for 20-to-30 reps).
  3. If you wish to acquire muscle, you must raise moderately-heavy weights for moderately-high reps (corresponding to 60-to-85% of your 1RM for 6-to-12 reps). 

The truth is that these guidelines are as pat as they’re ubiquitous. 

Over the previous few years, research have been piling up exhibiting that high-, low-, and moderate-rep ranges are all equally efficient for gaining muscle. Particularly, you possibly can acquire equal quantities of muscle utilizing any rep vary from 3-to-35 reps per set, supplied you are taking every set inside a couple of reps of failure.

That stated, it’s nonetheless not clear if “low-load coaching” (lifting mild weights, usually for prime reps) is the equal of upper load coaching in all respects.

For instance, research present which you can construct muscle utilizing moderately-heavy weights even in the event you don’t take your units to failure (the purpose at which you’ll be able to not transfer a weight regardless of giving your full effort), however is that this true of lighter weights? 

We additionally know which you can maintain constructing muscle for years utilizing moderately-heavy weights, however with lighter weights? 

Some people additionally say that you must use low-load coaching in a periodized vogue—spending a couple of months utilizing lighter weights after which switching again to reasonable or heavy weights, however is that this true?

It’s questions like these that scientists on the Nationwide and Kapodistrian College of Athens sought to reply once they randomly break up 41 bodily lively women and men into 3 teams: a low-load group that used 30% of their 1RM, a moderate-load group that used 70% of their 1RM, and a management group that didn’t raise weights.

Each teams adopted a 3-day coaching program for 12 weeks. Every exercise consisted of 4 rounds of the bench press, again squat, bent-over row, deadlift, and shoulder press carried out as a circuit in that order with 30 seconds relaxation between units and a pair of.5 minutes between circuits. Unusually, as an alternative of assigning every group a selected rep goal per set, that they had them do as many reps as they may for 30 seconds. Because the low-load group was utilizing lighter weights, they have been capable of carry out extra reps, however this design creates a couple of points we’ll handle in a second.

The outcomes confirmed that over the course of the research, each teams accomplished roughly the identical quantity load (units × reps × weight). Particularly, the low-load group lifted a complete of ~43,300 kilos and the moderate-load group lifted a complete of ~41,900 kilos.

Each teams gained about the identical quantity of energy on every train, although the moderate-load group acquired barely stronger general.

Relating to physique composition, the low-load group misplaced significantly extra fats (-7 lb. vs. -3.6 lb.), and each teams gained an identical quantity of muscle (~2.4 lb. for the low-load group and ~2.7 lb. for the moderate-load group).

That stated, they gained muscle at totally different charges all through the research. The moderate-load group gained a median of ~2.3 lb. of muscle in the course of the first 6 weeks of the research, however solely ~0.4 lb. of muscle in the course of the last 6 weeks. The low-load group gained a median of ~1 lb. of muscle within the first 6 weeks and ~1.4 lb. within the last 6 weeks.

This would appear to torpedo the concept that low-load coaching “stops working” the longer you do it. That stated, the researchers used bioelectrical impedance evaluation (BIA) to measure muscle acquire, which is fraught with errors, so it’s attainable this quirky outcome was simply an artifact of defective measurement.

And what of the significance (or lack thereof) of coaching near failure? 

This research doesn’t present a transparent reply, however not directly suggests you may make good positive factors coaching with lighter weights for prime reps even in the event you don’t take your units to failure.  

As a result of each teams have been restricted to lifting weights for simply 30 seconds per set, the low-load group was in all probability stopping their units lengthy earlier than they reached failure. Principally, they weren’t “allowed” to do as many reps per set as they in all probability may have, but they nonetheless gained about as a lot muscle as the parents utilizing moderately-heavy weights.

This stands to motive, as a result of analysis exhibits that forcing your muscle groups to provide mechanical pressure is the best strategy to construct muscle, and you are able to do this utilizing mild weights for prime reps or heavy weights for low reps. 

In different phrases, each strategies produce pressure, however in barely alternative ways. For those who prepare with mild weights and excessive reps, every rep produces a comparatively small quantity of pressure, however you make up for this by doing extra complete reps. For those who prepare with heavier weights and decrease reps, every rep produces a number of pressure, however you possibly can solely do a handful earlier than it’s a must to finish the set. And as long as you’re step by step including weight and/or reps over time (progressive pressure overload), you possibly can construct muscle with both strategy.

There are a couple of caveats to contemplate, although.

First, there’s a level the place larger rep units with lighter weights ceases to be efficient for muscle constructing. Take biking, for instance, which is only a high-rep, low-load leg exercise. Whereas that is nice for constructing endurance, it’s clearly not as efficient for constructing muscle as squats. For this reason researchers think about the higher restrict of efficient high-rep coaching to be round ~35-to-40 reps (the burden you’re utilizing must be sufficiently heavy that you can solely do 35-to-40 reps with it earlier than needing to cease).

Second, the weightlifters on this research carried out every exercise as a circuit, and it’s attainable this will likely have handicapped the advantages of the moderate-load coaching. If the individuals had been allowed to relaxation a couple of minutes between units throughout their moderately-heavy exercises as an alternative of simply 30 seconds, they could have gained fairly a bit extra muscle and energy than the group utilizing lighter weights for larger reps. 

Third, as talked about a second in the past, muscle acquire was measured utilizing BIA, which might be fickle and inconsistent. Given the small absolute variations between the teams, it’s not out of the query that a lot of the distinction could possibly be chalked as much as the foibles of BIA. 

Fourth, the parents on this research have been comparatively new to weightlifting, which implies they’re nonetheless doubtless having fun with some stage of beginner positive factors. Whereas different research have proven that extra skilled weightlifters may also successfully acquire muscle utilizing lower-load coaching, it’s nonetheless not clear if that is as universally efficient as reasonable hundreds. 

Lastly, even when high-rep, low-load coaching actually is as efficient as heavy coaching, there are a number of sensible causes for favoring lower-rep, higher-load exercises as an alternative: it’s usually extra time-efficient, extra enjoyable (you get to make use of heavier weights), higher suited to explicit workouts (like deadlifts), and far and away higher for gaining energy. 

That isn’t to say low-load coaching has no place in a well-designed energy coaching program, however it needs to be a a lot decrease precedence than heavy weightlifting. A great rule of thumb is to do about 80% of your units within the 4-to-10 rep vary and 20% above or under that (which is analogous to what I like to recommend in my packages for women and men, Larger Leaner Stronger and Thinner Leaner Stronger).

TL;DR: Coaching with mild weights could also be as efficient at serving to you acquire muscle as coaching with heavier weights, even while you prepare removed from failure, however it ought to nonetheless make up a comparatively small fraction of your exercises. 

Discover the Good Dietary supplements for You in Simply 60 Seconds

You do not want dietary supplements to construct muscle, lose fats, and get wholesome. However the correct ones will help. Take this quiz to study which of them are greatest for you.

Take the Quiz

Does consuming a bigger breakfast assist you burn extra energy all through the day?

Supply: “Twice as Excessive Food regimen-Induced Thermogenesis After Breakfast vs Dinner On Excessive-Calorie as Nicely as Low-Calorie Meals” printed in March 1, 2020 in The Journal of Scientific Endocrinology and Metabolism.

Nutrient timing is a favourite hobbyhorse amongst many food plan gurus for a similar motive most fad diets are interesting: 

It offers an escape from the uncomfortable actuality that you should eat fewer energy than you burn to shed extra pounds. 

As an example, you’ve in all probability heard that in the event you don’t eat after 7, or 8, or 9 p.m. (or one other arbitrary time within the night) . . . or in the event you simply confine your consuming to 1 or two meals per day . . . or simply skip breakfast . . . or quick for one or two days per week . . . then you definitely don’t want to fret about your calorie consumption. 

Or in the event that they’re a much less unscrupulous charlatan, perhaps they’ll concede that energy matter, however contend that their explicit nutrient timing technique will nonetheless assist you lose extra fats than you’d in any other case.   

For those who perceive the idea of power steadiness, although, you already know that that is bunk. Research present your basal metabolic fee (the minimal variety of energy your physique wants to remain alive, which most individuals discuss with as “your metabolic fee”) barely adjustments all through the day, and will even barely enhance in the course of the evening.

In case your metabolism doesn’t stall in the course of the night, and energy eaten at evening aren’t inherently extra fattening than energy eaten earlier within the day, are there any advantages to consuming much less at evening?


Some analysis means that consuming extra energy earlier within the day might enhance the thermic impact of meals (TEF)—the variety of energy your physique burns digesting the meals you eat. 

One of the best instance of this comes from a research carried out by scientists on the College of Lubeck, the place 16 wholesome, non-obese males reported to the lab for 2 3-day visits that have been separated by not less than 2 weeks. 

Throughout one go to (large-breakfast situation), they consumed a big share of their each day energy at breakfast (69%), a smaller share of their each day energy at lunch (20%), and a good smaller share of their each day energy at dinner (11%).

And in the course of the different go to (large-dinner situation), they consumed most of their each day energy at dinner (69%), fewer at lunch (20%), and even fewer at breakfast (11%).

The researchers ensured the individuals consumed the identical variety of energy and the identical quantity protein, carbs, and fats in every go to. In addition they measured the participant’s power expenditure earlier than and after breakfast and dinner on every day of the research, after which averaged the outcomes to see which consuming schedule produced the very best TEF over the course of the research. Lastly, they measured the participant’s stage of starvation and need for sweets earlier than every meal and a number of other hours after dinner.

The outcomes confirmed that in the course of the large-breakfast situation, the individuals skilled over twice as a lot TEF as they did in the course of the large-dinner situation, which might equate to round 50-to-100 energy per day. 

Through the large-breakfast situation they have been additionally much less hungry all through the day and had fewer cravings for sweets

Thus, this research would appear to be vindication of the longstanding concept that you must eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince, and dinner like a pauper (and maybe snack like a knight?).  For those who take the outcomes at face worth, then front-loading your energy at breakfast would inevitably assist you shed extra pounds with none additional work in your half.

Earlier than you rejigger your meal plan, although, it’s price contemplating a couple of caveats.

First, in the event you’re already consuming a big breakfast, then it’s not clear if consuming much more energy earlier within the day may have further advantages. For instance, in the event you’re already consuming 800 energy within the morning, it’s unsure if consuming much more than this may maintain pushing your TEF larger and better. 

Second, and most significantly, this research wasn’t a real apples to apples comparability between the TEF of breakfast and dinner. We don’t must get into the nitty gritty particulars of the research design, however the lengthy story brief is that the researchers reported TEF by way of a share enhance from baseline—not complete variety of energy burned. 

This issues as a result of within the large-breakfast situation, the individuals consumed most of their energy after an in a single day quick, which implies their baseline TEF ranges could be close to all-time low. Within the large-dinner situation, although, they ate most of their energy having already eaten breakfast and lunch, which implies their TEF was in all probability already elevated (since they’d nonetheless be digesting their earlier meals).

Subsequently, it’s attainable the rationale the large-dinner group skilled a smaller relative enhance in TEF is as a result of their TEF ranges have been larger to start with.

Consider it this fashion: Think about you’re driving at 30 miles per hour (mph) then speed up to 60 mph (rising your velocity by 30 mph). Then, one other driver who’s parked close by accelerates to 60 mph (rising their velocity by 60 mph).

Who’s going sooner?

Neither of you—you’re going the identical velocity, however the different driver skilled a bigger share enhance of their velocity than you. 

It’s attainable the identical factor occurred on this research—TEF was already revved up within the large-dinner situation, and thus the share enhance was smaller than that of the large-breakfast situation.

Right here’s what this all means: it’s attainable that each teams really burned the identical absolute variety of energy from TEF, however the large-breakfast group skilled a bigger share enhance in calorie burning after consuming their morning meal.

Lengthy story brief: the seeming superiority of consuming a giant breakfast on this research might have extra to do with how calorie burning was measured than some inherent fat-burning advantage of consuming extra earlier within the day.  

Third, one other limitation to this research is that the individuals didn’t train, so we don’t know if the outcomes would apply to individuals who train often. Analysis exhibits that train might enhance TEF no matter while you eat, and it additionally has constructive results on urge for food, which may have affected the outcomes.

It’s additionally attainable that the rationale the large-dinner group skilled much less TEF is that they weren’t used to consuming such a big dinner. 

Analysis means that following a constant meal schedule might enhance TEF and following an irregular meal schedule might lower TEF. This implies it’s attainable that after the folks within the large-dinner group turned accustomed to consuming extra of their energy within the night, they might have skilled simply as a lot TEF because the large-breakfast group.

Lastly, there’s another reason to doubt consuming within the morning is healthier than consuming within the night: intermittent fasting.

This in style technique often includes skipping breakfast and consuming most of your energy later within the day, and analysis exhibits it’s simply as efficient at selling weight reduction as diets that embrace breakfast.

In sum, consuming extra energy within the morning may enhance power expenditure and reduce cravings, however there are various causes to doubt that is the case, and even when it have been true, the advantages could be small.

How a lot you eat over the long-term goes to have a a lot bigger impact in your physique composition than while you eat. However in the event you’re already in a calorie deficit, consuming extra energy within the morning might assist you burn a couple of extra energy per day and really feel much less hungry. On condition that starvation is subjective by nature, mess around with consuming kind of energy earlier within the day and see how this impacts your urge for food (simply don’t count on it that can assist you shed extra pounds by itself). 

If all of this has you interested in the ins and outs of correct weight-reduction plan—what number of energy, how a lot of every macronutrient, and which meals you must eat to succeed in your health objectives—take the Legion Food regimen Quiz and in lower than a minute, you’ll know precisely what food plan is best for you. Click on right here to test it out.)

TL;DR: Though this research appeared to point out that consuming a bigger breakfast helps you burn extra energy all through the day, there are myriad causes to doubt the outcomes. Most research present that while you eat doesn’t have an effect on weight reduction by any means.

Discover the Finest Food regimen for You in Simply 60 Seconds

What number of energy must you eat? What about “macros?” What meals must you eat? Take our 60-second quiz to get science-based solutions to those questions and extra.

Take the Quiz

L-theanine helps anxious folks cool their jets.

Supply: “Anti-stress impact of theanine on college students throughout pharmacy apply: constructive correlation amongst salivary α-amylase exercise, trait nervousness and subjective stress” printed on September 16, 2013 in Pharmacology Biochemistry and Conduct.

L-theanine is an amino acid discovered primarily in tea. For many years it flew underneath the radar as simply one other ho-hum chemical in tea till some research confirmed that it may work synergistically with caffeine to amplify its advantages (elevated focus and psychological acuity) and mute its downsides (elevated blood strain and nervousness). Since then it’s turn out to be an increasing number of widespread to see L-theanine alongside caffeine in pre-workout dietary supplements (like Pulse), however it nonetheless isn’t usually taken by itself.

One of many causes for that is that there simply aren’t many research on L-theanine as a standalone complement, which is why it’s price perusing the few that exist. 

To wit, one research carried out by scientists on the College of Shizuoka investigated how L-theanine affected folks’s stress ranges. They break up 20 fifth-year pharmacy college students who have been assigned to practices (hospitals or drug shops—which are sometimes annoying locations to work) into 2 teams: a gaggle that supplemented with L-theanine and a gaggle that took a placebo.

The L-theanine group took 200 milligrams of L-theanine twice per day, one 100 mg pill after breakfast and the opposite after lunch, whereas the placebo group took inert capsules as an alternative. The researchers additionally instructed the individuals to keep away from caffeine and different merchandise which may comprise L-theanine, like tea, to keep away from confounding the outcomes. 

The individuals took the dietary supplements for 1 week earlier than going to their jobs (part 1) and continued for the next 10 days whereas on the job (part 2). Throughout this time, the researchers recorded a number of organic and subjective measures of stress.

The outcomes confirmed that supplementing with L-theanine after breakfast prevented any enhance in salivary α-amylase (a marker of stress) within the morning, although it had much less of an impact after a tough day’s work.

This implies that L-theanine is efficient at curbing anticipatory nervousness (working your self right into a lather over future occasions), however in all probability doesn’t assist you take care of all types of stress.

L-theanine additionally boosted subjective well-being amongst individuals who confirmed indicators of excessive trait nervousness (individuals who the researchers deemed to be extra more likely to really feel anxious throughout annoying conditions primarily based on their solutions to a questionnaire), although once more it was much less efficient in people who didn’t have excessive trait nervousness.

In sum, L-theanine didn’t “work” for everybody, however it took the sting off annoying occasions for individuals who wanted it most.

Complement firms will proceed to pair L-theanine with caffeine in pre-workout dietary supplements as a result of it does an awesome job “pruning” the results of caffeine—taking away a number of the unhealthy whereas enhancing the great.

This proof suggests, nonetheless, that L-theanine might cut back nervousness by itself with few to no uncomfortable side effects.

And in the event you’re all for a 100% pure L-theanine complement that additionally accommodates 5 different components that enhance temper, sharpen psychological focus, enhance energy, energy, and endurance, and cut back fatigue, attempt Pulse.

(Or in the event you aren’t certain if Pulse is best for you or if one other complement is likely to be a greater match in your price range, circumstances, and objectives, then take the Legion Complement Finder Quiz! In lower than a minute, it’ll let you know precisely what dietary supplements are best for you. Click on right here to test it out.)

TL;DR: L-theanine helps you are feeling much less careworn about upcoming occasions and reduces nervousness in power worriers.

+ Scientific References


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles

Impartial MP Zoe Daniel requires higher consuming dysfunction funding

We commend and thank Zoe Daniel and fellow federal impartial members for shining a nationwide highlight on...

Operating Sneakers Are on Main Sale at Nordstrom Proper Now

Initially $320, now $240 Out there sizes: 5-11 (in half sizes, choose offered out) When the...

Turning into Vegetarian After Consuming Dysfunction Restoration

Vegetarian diets have been gaining recognition in recent times...